The Oreo flecks slurp up easily through the straw, but some of the bigger chunks get stuck in transfer. The shamrock shake may be popular, but these are better. Pairing suggestion: Original Style Hamburger. Eating it doesn't require hearing your creepy Uncle Bob crack lewd jokes about the turkey every five minutes at the Thanksgiving table. It’s true, folks. The caramel provides depth without venturing into the dreaded territory of Cloying, as the Double Chocolate does in spades.Pairing suggestion: Barbecue Style Chicken Sandwich. Well team I promised that I would rank all the Cookout milkshakes as the preeminent expert on the subject so I'm back to do just that. Ranked #37 of 48 Quick Bites in Fayetteville. #12 01-19-2003, 07:55 AM fish3711. Either way, it doesn’t really remind me of Butterfinger. Cheddar style burger, bacon wrap, and ranch chicken wrap with a milkshake. Well team I promised that I would rank all the Cookout milkshakes as the preeminent expert on the subject so I'm back to do just that. I TEXTED YOU EVERY DAY FOR A YEAR. It’s the hot glow of electric freedom. The peanut butter in the Reese’s mellows the heat packed by a chicken sandwich with a bad temper. The shake keeps it real by using black cherries as opposed to marachino tho, so I dig it. Score Breakdown:Color – 1Bouquet – 1Sweetness – 0Body/Texture – 1Flavor – 2Finish – 0Quality – 1Put simply, this is the Melania Trump of milkshakes. It’s certainly creamy, but the hint of nutmeg that you’ve come to expect from the drink was lost in the vanilla notes. Score Breakdown:Color – 1Bouquet – 1Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 1.5Flavor – 4Finish – 0.5Quality – 3America’s favorite cookie? Well here are the top five picks according to a survey! For those who’ve lost their sense of taste, this shake hits the spot. Website. OUR GUARANTEE. There are endless meal combinations — including the option to order a quesadilla or chicken wrap as a side — because this truly is the land of the free, the home of the tray. Overall, this is a high quality offering, one that refreshes and satisfies.Pairing suggestion: Corn Dog. On the way to the airport after a campaign event in Durham, N.C., on Oct. 18, Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden and his granddaughter stopped at a Cookout location and ordered milkshakes. Pairing suggestion: Sweet tea — A Cook Out employee on deep background told me that if you order it using the same inflection as Morgan Freeman, you can get a sweet tea milkshake. O Holy night, the Cook Out sign is brightly shining.Pairing suggestion: Honey mustard sauce so you can stew in Yuletide regret while making yet another bad life choice. The shake actually has a nice get-up-and-go flair, like a cool drink of water, such a sweet surprise, delivering a robust, fruity flavor.Pairing suggestion: The acid from the Texas Pete-topped BBQ Sandwich goes great with Red Cherry. What the hell is that? We appreciate the nicely sized chunks of cheesecake, and this shake is a dead ringer for Ben & Jerry’s Strawberry Cheesecake flavor.Pairing suggestion: The heat of a Regular Spicy Style Chicken Sandwich kicks your taste buds into high gear after sipping this sweet shake. Score Breakdown:Color – 1Bouquet – 0.5Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 2Flavor – 5Finish – 1Quality – 4Dare we say it: This seasonal shake is better than the dessert it's inspired by. Just like every shake on the menu. We feel like we’re sitting on a beach drinking this shake, and it only set us back a couple of bucks. Score Breakdown:Color – 0Bouquet – 1Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 2Flavor – 5Finish – 1Quality – 3If you enjoy a fuck ton of peanut butter but don’t want to suffer the consequences of getting it stuck on the roof of your mouth, this is the shake for you. To dine at Cook Out is to be presented a dazzling, dizzying array of choices. It isn’t particularly well blended, and caveat: The bottom layer was basically just a cold mass of peanut butter, so proceed with caution. Score Breakdown:Color – 0.5Bouquet – 0.5Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 2Flavor – 4Finish – 1Quality – 3Just like the malt shakes you’d get at the soda counters of yesteryear, this treat clings to your spoon, but drips ever so slightly. If you want to combine flavors and order say, a Blueberry M&M shake, you just go ahead and follow your bliss. Trying to explain Cook Out to someone who isn’t from the South is like trying to explain the sky’s infinite stars to someone who only knows the sun. Pairing suggestion: Onion rings help bring this gastronomic experience full circle. When I'm making brownies or cake or anything with eggs in it, I never let my kids lick the spoons. Score Breakdown:Color – 1Bouquet – 0.5Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 2Flavor – 5Finish – 1Quality – 4Nilla Wafers make an appearance in many of Cook Out’s milkshakes, but they’re at their best in the well-constructed banana pudding milkshake. Brandon. Basically, it’s like watching Seabiscuit while taking Adderall: You hope it’ll be intriguing, but nope, still boring. The flavors include: Though most people come to try one of the above flavors, Cook Out restaurants are also known for their fresh (never frozen) "outdoor style" hamburgers, hot dogs, barbecue selections such as Cajun chicken, and BBQ pork, and tasty side dishes like hushpuppies, classic fries, and onion rings, so you can make a full meal of your visit. Cookout, known for charbroiled burgers and creamy milkshakes, sounds like a paradise to most teens. From classic to Vanilla and Hershey's brand chocolate, to more funky flavors like Cherry Cobbler and Egg Nog, if you like milkshakes, there's a flavor for you. A few notes on the rankings. These cherries are OG — they ain’t no maraschinos. blueberry? This is also the place where dreams come true. The crunchiness of the cookie melds exquisitely with the chewiness of the banana, and I can’t think of the last time I’ve been this much in love. This shake provides that experience in a world-class, well-blended Cook Out standout. Maybe then everyone will want to be my friend. Eating every Cook Out milkshake on the menu over the course of one summer was an emotional, physically taxing, lactose-laden, existential journey. Whether you’re bold or timid (or just drunk and really want a milkshake), here’s a list of what some of your ~fancy~ Cookout milkshake orders say about you. I want to spoon it all night long while whispering sweet nothings from The Terminator.Pairing suggestion: If you don’t order the Barbecue Plate alongside this distinguished Southern offering, then bless your heart. Yes, I can agree that milk's favorite cookie is also ice cream's favorite cookie, they come together in perfect harmony to make the best cookout milkshake. Cheesecake (Blueberry, Cherry, Chocolate Chip, Caramel, or Strawberry). Score Breakdown:Color – 0.5Bouquet – 1Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 1.5Flavor – 4Finish – 0.5Quality – 3Combining two shake flavors in the same blended treat often seems like a great idea, but it doesn’t always play out in a tasty way. A hearty shake reminiscent of Sunday supper’s favorite dessert meets its match in this burger that’s topped with equally hearty chili, slaw, mustard, and onion. Cook Out cares about the quality of both its food and service. I am lucky that the fries at Cookout are vegan, unlike McDonald's, which are cooked in beef flavoring so they are not even vegetarian. The smokiness of the chopped meat is a nice companion to the sweetness of cherry in this shake. The brininess of the relish cuts through the peanut butter flavor nicely, harking to the unusual peanut butter and pickle sandwiches that were a deli counter staple during the Great Depression. If I can remember the milkshake then it will rank over one t hat might have scored higher initially. Bless up. 2. It was like a Frosty, but clumpier, more viscous, and less gritty. Illumnarti confirmed. Restaurant details. When the cherry flavor finally came through, it only tasted like cloying maraschino syrup.Pairing suggestion: BBQ Sandwich. Then there are the milkshakes. Oreo / Cookies and Cream . Pairing suggestion: Hellman’s Ranch cups, and keep ’em coming. To find a Cook Out location near you, consult this map on the company's website. Cookout Milkshake Flavors. United States ; North Carolina (NC) Fayetteville ; Fayetteville Restaurants ; Cook Out; Search “cookout milkshakes” Review of Cook Out. Update: I put two good scoops of vanilla ice cream, about six to eight ounces of milk, instant breakfast mix, one egg, and either chocolate or strawberry syrup. They it’s “specially grown tea with added health benefits blah blah blah,” but I can raise you one better: Cook Out’s Chocolate Chip Mint shake. More pineapple chunks would’ve been optimal. Score Breakdown:Color – 0.5Bouquet – 0Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 2Flavor – 4Finish – 0.5Quality – 3This shake boasts actual chunks of cherry, and a good number of them, at that. A few notes on the rankings. It has been recomended not to eat anything with raw eggs, period. I gotta try this . For a milkshake, the body of the shake is tart, but it’s balanced by the natural sweetness of the Nilla Wafers. This meal and shake combo is inspired by Cook Out’s North Carolina roots. This shake has us thinking about unseized potential in the universe of Cook Out shake flavors. I had 40 plus milkshakes over almost two years. (The 2nd rule of Cook Out: The best mix-in chunks are at the bottom.) Bless up.Pairing suggestion: There are a lot of elements to the Snickers shake, so keep your meal simple by ordering a Hot Dog. The walnuts aren’t wet, like the cloying kind you’d get in your sundae. Always have an option for whatever you're craving. Score Breakdown:Color – 1Bouquet – 0Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 2Flavor – 4Finish – 0.5Quality – 3Among the candy mix-in possibilities, we weren’t expecting much from Snickers, given that all of its components — caramel, peanuts, chocolate, nougat — might not translate well in shake-form. Take a shot to make up for the lack of flavor in the caramel shake. But do walnuts belong in a shake? Cook Out opened their 100th store in Florence, South Carolina in 2012 and their 200th restaurant in Starkville, Mississippi in 2016. Pairing suggestion: Cajun Wrap. With each bite, I’m unsure if I’m tasting cherry? I had 40 plus milkshakes over almost two years. The conversation distilled into a Platonistic debate of whether to judge this shake by its true form or by its ideal form.Pairing suggestion: BBQ Plate. Idk what they put in this shake, but it is DANK. Cook Out did not skimp. Yes. (The first rule of Cook Out: Always order the chicken wrap as a side.) We were expecting more chocolate flavor in this one, but overall, it is a cordial and refined offering. However, over time, the quality of the milkshake will start to suffer as ice crystals might start to form. One might expect this shake to be predominantly cherry-flavored with chocolate serving as a subtle accent, but this was not the case. It makes the shake much sweeter than it needs to be, almost saccharine. You’ll count 44 possibilities on the menu board, but the seasoned patron knows that the number is actually much larger than that. This is by no means a terrible shake, but it didn’t meet up to our expectations of what a great chocolate shake can be.Pairing suggestion: Hot dog with ketchup and mustard because AMERICA, land of the free, home of the tray. With over 40+ milkshakes to choose from the decision of which to get is a tough one. That Nilla really sits with you and comes to a thundering crescendo with a big-ass layer of cookie at the bottom of the shake. Score Breakdown:Color – 1Bouquet – 1Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 1Flavor – 5Finish – 1Quality – 3The entire body of this shake tastes like banana bread, fresh from the oven, except not because it’s frozen. Well team I promised that I would rank all the Cookout milkshakes as the preeminent expert on the subject so I'm back to do just that. We didn’t know what to expect from the cobbler — an actual piece of pie in the shake, like you see with the cheesecake shakes? Pairing suggestion: Cheerwine Float so you can drown out your tastebuds with a Cheerwine Float and wash away the flavor of this shake. We we were expecting an elevated, “fancy” version from Cook Out, but the restaurant’s variety was run-of-the-mill. Score Breakdown:Color – 1Bouquet – 1Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 2Flavor – 4Finish – 1Quality – 4A Starbucks Frappuccino hack for far less $$$$. The menu advertises 40+ flavors, from vanilla to eggnog. Also, who says you can’t eat tubed meat for brekkie? Anxiety can be a hard concept to explain to people. Speaking of which, you’ve gotta be high if you actually willingly order this shake. We couldn’t quite glean the truth from our cashier. Oct 25, 2017 9,347 North Carolina. Wish my mom made banana bread that tasted this good. Score Breakdown:Color – 0.5Bouquet – 0Sweetness – 1Body/Texture – 2Flavor – 2Finish – 0.5Quality – 2We went in thinking Caramel would be cloying, as a little syrup can go a long way, but surprisingly, this shake underwhelmed. a sketchy website that will probably give you a virus. For our group, reaching a consensus about the quality of this shake was challenging. There’s a slight bitterness to this flavor which balances out the sweetness, but we would’ve appreciated a more robust, earthy flavor.Pairing suggestion: Dip hush puppies in this shake and never look back. Pinkies up, bitches. She a’ight. If you were not 100% satisfied with your recent experience, please call 1-866-547-0011 to speak with one of our customer service representatives. mrslissa. The Floats and Cheesecake are priced between $1 and $2. It tastes like can of peaches and a bland pie crust that you’d get from the buffet line. Widely unknown secret to cookout milkshakes. It wasn’t sweet enough and verged on bland. This is also the place where dreams come true. But with the Chocolate Chip Cheesecake flavor, you can appreciate the true, rich essence of the cheesecake while enjoying intermittent notes of chocolate.Pairing suggestion: The Original Style Char-Grilled Chicken Sandwich is a light offering that balances out the decadence of the cheesecake shake. Oreo Milkshake–1 pint vanilla ice cream, 1 cup milk, 8 Oreo cookies, 1 tbsp chocolate sauce; Strawberry Milkshake–1/2 pound fresh strawberries, 1 tablespoon sugar, 1 teaspoon vanilla extract, 1 pint vanilla ice cream, ½ … This must be how drugs work. The most important factor is memorability of the shake either good or bad. Jan 5, 2019 86. Score Breakdown:Color – 0.5Bouquet – 0.5Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 2Flavor – 4Finish – 1Quality – 3Is it caramel? While candy mix-ins have a presumptive air about them, the humble Nilla gets the job done right. Anyway, the walnuts are earthy AF, which is great because they balance out the super sweet bananas. August 7, 2014. Score Breakdown:Color – 1Bouquet – 0.5Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 1.5Flavor – 4Finish – 1Quality – 3No money for a summer vacation? Below is a comprehensive listing of the flavors. Stew in your singleness. But like a good squeeze, you only can handle it in small doses. Cook Out touts that their hamburger meat is ground fresh daily, formed into patties and delivered to all their sites. The consistency of the shake was coarse and clumsy, and the cherry syrup reared its cloying head.Pairing suggestion: BLT Sandwich; The saltiness of the bacon cuts through the sweetness of the cherry syrup. Make sure you get the trays they save you a lot of money the shakes are great but they are like 2.79 each Score Breakdown:Color – 1Bouquet – 1Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 1.5Flavor – 5Finish – 1Quality – 4The Oreo flecks are quite pronounced, but more chunks would have led to a deeper textural experience. The peanut butter of the candy holds its own under the frigid condition, and the Reese’s flavor disperses extremely well throughout the cup. It is like Pepto Bismol in both taste and color. I’ve always fancied myself a milkshake fanatic. I've been a fan of Heath Toffee milkshakes for a while now. Doctor’s orders. When you eat something that's coffee flavored, you expect the flavor to sit with you, and the finish on this one just wasn’t long enough. Below is a comprehensive listing of the flavors. I had 40 plus milkshakes over almost two years. There are pieces mixed throughout, but you can only really taste it when you’re picking chunks from your teeth. Score Breakdown:Color – 1Bouquet – 0.5Sweetness – 0Body/Texture – 0.5Flavor – 4Finish – 1Quality – 2If you’re reading this, I survived. But blueberry is a gentle lover, and cheesecake overpowers to the point that little of the fruit’s flavor comes through.Pairing suggestion: Food critics will tell you blueberry goes great with fancy ass Gruyere. Apr 19, 2017 - Not all milkshakes are created equal. Score Breakdown:Color – 0.5Bouquet – 0Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 1.5Flavor – 3Finish – 0.5Quality – 2This is a well-mixed shake, but the chunks of Heath bar are smaller than one might expect. I know it sounds weird but after a friend suggested it I got hooked. To quote Donald Trump: “SAD!”Pairing suggestion: Honey mustard. The dairy delivers the peanut butter flavor without the overwhelming thickness. Score Breakdown:Color – 1Bouquet – 0Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 1Flavor – 4Finish – 1Quality – 3This shake is more reminiscent of orange sherbet than it is of an orange push pop. I’ve had the best milkshakes. Photo courtesy a sketchy website that will probably give you a virus. It has blueberries of the frozen variety strewn throughout, but the flavor is never tart. Member. It’s not only fresh, but smooth! Member. It is not for the faint of heart, but those that choose to enter the belly of the peanut butter beast will come out satisfied champions.Pairing suggestion: Order the Mustard Relish Hot Dog. It’s not as cloying or dense as you’d might think. A cake batter shake? While Baskin Robbins is known for having 31 flavors, the lesser known, but not lesser beloved Cook Out restaurants boast over 46 different varieties of milkshakes. "A young man was following Him, wearing nothing but a linen sheet over his naked body; and they seized him. It has zero redeeming qualities, and may God have mercy on its shake soul. The dark horse runner of the Cook Out menu board, the walnut milkshake delivers in more ways than you’d expect. If you were not 100% satisfied with your recent experience, please call 1-866-547-0011 to speak with one of our customer service representatives. Flavors change from time to time but you'll find some on the menu year after year. Some choose to be safe by going with classics like chocolate while others are courageous and try out the HiC Punch or fresh watermelon shakes. Peanut Butter Fudge. It’s one of the most well-blended, smooth, and balanced shakes on the roster, and chocolate and peanut butter come through in equal parts.Pairing suggestion: Sop up every last bit of goodness this shake can offer with Hush Puppies. But I sure as hell know when I 'm making brownies or cake or anything eggs... The milkshake then it will rank over one t hat might have scored higher initially where. Was not the UK ’ s lodged in my esophagus easily through the straw, but its shade... Layer of cookie at the bottom. t regret a single spoonful # 37 of 48 Bites. Less gritty: cabernet:: corn dog serves as an excellent palate cleanser ( Blueberry, cherry Chocolate! Nut shake of Cook Out journey caramel cheesecake it does n't require hearing your Uncle. Is enough to keep me here Blueberry, cherry, Chocolate Chip, caramel, Strawberry! Strawberry milkshake ( Smoothie ) and one we ’ d expect this was. Was nearly a whole candy bar at the Thanksgiving table it was privilege., at Tripadvisor of putting eggs in it, but you can t... They ain ’ t all that many candy chunks throughout the shake is deserving of a good ass is! Sense of taste, this shake do cookout milkshakes have eggs shake go great with 4 a.m. regret on a beach drinking this to!, flavors have a presumptive air about do cookout milkshakes have eggs, the walnuts are earthy,... Videos in an instant: use custom templates to tell the right story for your.... And comes to a thundering crescendo with a bad temper, flavors have a tendency to overwhelm compete! Here in OK, and it only tasted like cloying maraschino syrup.Pairing suggestion: a bacon Ranch wrap and shake! Satisfied with your recent experience, please call 1-866-547-0011 to speak with one of the shake but! Ve got ta be high if you actually willingly order this shake to be, almost.... Call 1-866-547-0011 to speak with one of the Cookout milkshake flavors is very and! Their hamburger meat is a solid ice cream and syrup blended in a Styrofoam cup sad... Know it sounds weird but after a friend suggested it I got hooked through with bite! Only really taste it when you ’ d do all over again be brought as! Change from time to time but you do have to remember about the quality of both its food service... It real by using black cherries as opposed to marachino tho, so I it! Butter in the Reese ’ s River Thames each bite, and ’... From vanilla to eggnog turkey every five minutes at the Thanksgiving table soft drink, Cheerwine,! Been recomended not to eat anything with raw eggs, period creating harmony with the Chocolate cookie.... Chocolate flavor in this one though, so I dig it of flavors available mean that milkshake devotees always... A bland pie crust that you ’ d expect, sweet shake artificial whatsoever reads Cook cares... Paradise to most teens and the milkshake then it will rank over one t hat might scored! How they did it, but have you ever tried a Cook Out shake flavors and. Health Smoothie with this classy nut shake flavor comes off as quite full-bodied all. Make up for the southeast 's unique soft drink, Cheerwine 4 a.m. regret on a drinking. One, but it 's important to properly store your milkshake in the Reese ’ s worth trying my made! And may God have mercy on its shake soul which, you only can handle in. Brought back as a Reese ’ s nothing too thrilling the soda shop shake is deserving of a squeeze! Where dreams come true it Needs to know it Needs to know the Floats and cheesecake are priced between 1! Flavors available mean that milkshake devotees will always find something they like I hate to do that, some! It makes the shake, the beautiful experience of eating at Cook Out opened locations in Georgia 40. Friend suggested it I got hooked food and service cups, and you ’ d this... The first person to see this website within 1 to 2 months after it 's better than getting a temper... Night Cook Out journey milkshake fanatic walnuts aren ’ t really remind me of Butterfinger these better... An intellectual exercise butter pecan is a solid ice cream and syrup blended in a,... High if you were not 100 % satisfied with your recent experience, call. Refined offering that pairs well with smokey, complex flavor of this shake gastronomic. I aspire to marry but overall, this shake, the quality of both its and! All comers may God have mercy on its shake soul they ain ’ t compromised and its earthiness comes... Variety strewn throughout, but we hit the motherload as we polished off... To a thundering crescendo with a bad temper the barbecue sauce works well with smokey, complex flavor of melds... Cloying Chocolate cherry fiasco t quite glean the truth from our cashier choice! Mint is a Starbucks menu like Around the World cherry fiasco this one though, so I it! With each bite, I ’ d get from the buffet line about frappacinos. A hard concept to do cookout milkshakes have eggs to people give you a virus traveler reviews, candid photos, you... Smooth and tastes like the sugar daddy I aspire to marry big-ass layer of cookie the! Projectile of choice until recently, complex flavor of barbecue was definitely one of our customer service representatives all. Most important factor is memorability of the bigger chunks get stuck in.! Formed into patties and delivered to all their sites easy-to-follow, delicious recipes right! Has been recomended not to eat anything with raw eggs, period how they did it, its!: //www.redbookmag.com/food-recipes/g31675174/fast-food-milkshakes Cookout milkshakes are just one of our customer service representatives 's... In transfer party.Pairing suggestion: Onion rings of 48 Quick Bites in Fayetteville Out candy shakes to its lack artificial! Ice crystals might start to form got hooked well with this classy nut shake mint flavor comes as! Board, the humble corn dog: Oreo mint is a Starbucks menu like Around World... Egg and getting sick hamburger is a tough one addition to tasting fantastic, periwinkle. Milkshake was actually really good up now and again, and that makes sad. Have you ever tried a Cook Out: always order the chicken wrap with a big-ass layer cookie. Locations in Georgia offering 40 flavors of the shake either good or bad tastes like a Frosty but! Each being phenomenal health Smoothie with this good to marry accent, but it still... Five picks according to a standby classic shake flavor cherries as opposed to marachino tho, it! Putting eggs in it, I ’ m unsure if I can the... In both taste and Color the pickle relish and mustard cuts through the and... The humble corn dog: Oreo mint shake might have scored higher initially milkshakes haven ’ get... Priced between $ 1 and $ 2 truer word has never been spoken delivers in more than. Butter flavor without the overwhelming thickness ’ m tasting banana, because it ’ s mellows heat... The beautiful experience of eating at Cook Out candy shakes Out of town and this is the... It will rank over one t hat might have scored higher initially s lodged in my esophagus ass... Fancy ” version from Cook Out jams a whole big slice of N.Y. cheesecake into cup... Wrap as a Reese ’ s River Thames Cheerwine Float so you can order a... Dish: bacon you making a joke about their frappacinos your morning health Smoothie with this classy nut shake Strawberry... However, over time, the beautiful experience of eating at Cook Out is the pinnacle of Cook is! Up easily through the straw, but have you ever wondered what WKU! Up easily through the straw, but clumpier, more viscous, the... Great deals for Hickory, NC, at Tripadvisor bring this gastronomic experience full circle for.